‘Why a submission of no case to answer in a Contentious Probate or Trust dispute is a high-risk trial tactic.’

In England a judge will almost always refuse to hear the submission unless the defendant elects to call no evidence. Court of Appeal cases like Benham v Kythira Investments Ltd = a severe procedural trap – the Irrevocable Election. That is because the defendant must state that they will stand or fall by their submission.

So, they waive their right to call their own witnesses or cross-examine further if the submission fails. In rare circumstances, a judge may allow a submission without forcing an election, but the standard practice is to demand it.

If the defendant makes the election and proceeds, the judge applies a very high legal threshold to evaluate the request.

The judge must evaluate the claimants evidence at its absolute highest.The submission will fail if a reasonable tribunal could find for the claimant on the essential elements of the dispute.It will only succeed if there is a complete absence of evidence supporting an essential element of the claim, or if the evidence provided by the claimant is inherently incredible or completely undermined during cross-examination.

Contentious Probate and Trust claims are inherently fact-specific, relying deeply on witness credibility, contemporaneous medical records, and the nuances of human relationships. It is exceptionally rare for a claimants case to have an absolute zero evidentiary value by the halfway mark.

If a defendant forces the issue, loses the submission, and has elected to call no evidence, the judge will rule on the claim using only the claimants uncontested narrative, almost guaranteeing that the defendant will lose the entire trial and face significant adverse costs orders.

The existence of this litigation risk is another reason why it is sensible to enter into Mediation at an early stage even in a case that is perceived by the opposing party to be weak – unless of course there is at least an 80% chance of an application for summary judgment or strike-out suceeding. The unknown factor from the outset which makes this almost impossible to calculate with any meaningful accuracy is the judge who will hear the application.

Real advocacy is not like what you see on TV. Judges are intellectually fallible, some in the lower courts are deeply flawed and like everybody else they are human. Because Contentious Probate relies so heavily on nuances of human relationships, capacity, and undue influence, many judges prefer a full trial over summary disposal unless the claim is completely fanciful. It is exceptionally difficult to prove that a claimants case has an absolute zero value early on. Witness statements and contemporaneous medical records often reveal unexpected shades of grey under cross-examination, making pre-trial assessments highly volatile. In probate disputes, costs frequently escalate to the point of swallowing the estates entire value. Mediation provides an escape mechanism to cap these costs before they become destructive.

View image


‘Why was an exceptionally durable, dense volcanic rock used to build the monuments at Puma Punku and Tiwanaku in western Bolivia and at Lake Van in Turkey?’


AI – ‘Despite being separated by thousands of miles and different eras, the builders at Puma Punku / Tiwanaku and around Lake Van chose dense volcanic andesite for the same practical, structural, and symbolic reasons.

1. Resistance to Erosion and Weathering

Both sites are located in extreme, harsh environments where softer stone would quickly disintegrate:

  • The Bolivian Altiplano (Tiwanaku): At over 12,500 feet (3,800 metres) above sea level, the climate features intense solar radiation, fierce winds, and severe diurnal temperature swings (rapid freezing and thawing cycles). Andesite’s low porosity prevents water from seeping into the stone and cracking it when it freezes.

[1]

  • The Lake Van Basin (Turkey): This high-altitude Anatolian region experiences heavily snowy, freezing winters and humid conditions near the lake. Andesite stands up exceptionally well to moisture and chemical weathering over millennia. [1]

2. High Compressive Strength for Megalithic Load-Bearing

Because andesite is a fine-grained, igneous volcanic rock, it has incredibly high compressive strength. This made it essential for supporting the immense structural weight of these monuments:

  • At Puma Punku, andesite was used for load-bearing structural facings, massive lintels, and the famous interlocking H-blocks.
  • In the Lake Van region, Urartian engineers used roughly dressed andesite blocks to construct the foundational platforms and massive defensive walls of citable fortresses (like Ayanis Castle) that needed to withstand military siege and seismic activity. [1, 2, 3, 4]

3. Ability to Hold Precise, Intricate Carvings

Despite its hardness, andesite fractures predictably and has a uniform texture, allowing masterful stone cutters to achieve clean, crisp lines that do not easily flake or crumble. [1]

  • Puma Punku’s builders exploited this property to achieve highly precise right angles, perfectly flush mortise-and-tenon joints, and smooth geometric reliefs without mortar. [1, 2]
  • Around Lake Van, medieval Armenian architects and Iron Age Urartians used it to carve highly detailed bas-reliefs, religious iconography, and royal cuneiform inscriptions that remain perfectly legible today. [1]

4. Prestige and Monumental Longevity

Ancient empires intentionally selected the hardest local materials to project power, permanence, and divine authority. Transporting these heavy stones—which required floating andesite blocks across Lake Titicaca in Bolivia or organizing complex state-run quarrying expeditions in Anatolia—was a deliberate display of a civilization’s advanced engineering capabilities and control over vast resources. [1, 2]’

Why would cultures between whom – according to archaeologists – there was never any contact – share the same system/methodology of aethetic symbolism?

Is this a pure coincidence?

‘If Art is a language then what is the grammar?’

AI – ‘Art functions as a language, though it operates as a non-verbal, visual system of communication rather than a literal one with strict, codified dictionaries.

While it lacks a rigid structure like French or Mandarin, it mirrors language by using structured symbols to transmit complex ideas, emotions, and narratives from one mind to another.

Here is how art fulfills the requirements of a true language:

1. It Has a Codified Vocabulary and Syntax

As established by art theorists, visual art relies on a universal set of building blocks and rules to convey meaning:

  • The Vocabulary: The Elements of Art (Line, Colour, Shape, Value, Texture, Space, Form) act as the “words.”
  • The Grammar: The Principles of Art (Balance, Contrast, Emphasis, Movement, Rhythm, Unity) dictate how those words are structured to make a cohesive statement.

2. It Transcends Cultural and Literal Barriers

Verbal languages are bound by geography and history. If you do not speak Japanese, a Japanese poem may tell you nothing. Art, however, operates on a visceral, biological level that can bypass literacy:

  • Universal Triggers: A jagged, erratic red line communicates tension or anger to almost any human viewer, regardless of where they were born.
  • Shared Human Experience: A sculpture depicting grief or triumph can be understood across thousands of years of human history without needing a translator.

3. It Communicates the “Inexpressible”

Philosopher Susanne Langer argued that art handles a specific type of communication: the forms of human feeling.

  • Verbal language is linear (one word after another) and often struggles to capture simultaneous, conflicting emotions.
  • Art is presentational (experienced all at once). It can express nuance, ambiguity, and deep psychological states that words simply cannot articulate. As the saying goes, “Art is what happens when words fail.”

The Counter-Argument: Where the Metaphor Breaks Down

While art is a language, it is a highly poetic and subjective one. Linguists point out a key difference:

  • Literal language relies on fixed definitions (a “chair” means a chair) so that two people can agree on an exact, objective message.
  • Art relies on evocation and open interpretation. An artist can embed a specific phrase in a painting, but the viewer brings their own history to the piece, creating a fluid, collaborative meaning.

In short, art is an open-ended, emotional dialect—a way for humans to speak to one another across time and space using sight, form, and feeling instead of sound.

The vocabulary consists of the Elements of Art (the raw materials), while its grammar consists of the Principles of Art (the rules for combining them). [1]

Just as verbal grammar structures words into coherent sentences, visual grammar dictates how an artist organizes sensory information to guide the viewer’s eye, create emphasis, and communicate meaning. [1]


The Linguistic Breakdown of Visual Art

To understand the grammar, it helps to look at how art maps to the foundational structures of spoken language:

Linguistic Component Visual Art Equivalent Description
Letters / Phonemes Marks & Fundamentals The basic physical gestures: brushstrokes, pencil pressures, or perspective coordinates.
Vocabulary / Words The Elements of Art The fundamental building blocks used to create imagery: Line, Shape, Form, Colour, Value, Texture, and Space.
Grammar / Syntax The Principles of Art The structural framework used to arrange the elements: Balance, Contrast, Emphasis, Movement, Pattern, Rhythm, and Unity.

How Visual Grammar Works in Practice

Verbal grammar ensures that words don’t just sit on a page as a random list. Similarly, visual grammar ensures that elements are arranged intentionally:

  • Syntax (Sentence Structure): In text, word order determines meaning (“The dog bit the man” vs. “The man bit the dog”). In art, Composition acts as syntax. Where you place a shape relative to the horizon or how you use Scale changes the hierarchy of the entire piece.
  • Punctuation: Contrast and Value function like periods, commas, or exclamation marks. A sharp, high-contrast edge acts as a visual exclamation point, forcing the viewer’s eye to stop and look. A soft, blended gradient acts like an ellipsis (…), letting the eye glide smoothly across the canvas. [1]
  • Modifiers (Adjectives & Adverbs): Colour temperature and Texture modify the “nouns” of a painting. A jagged, rough texture modifies a simple square shape to make it feel aggressive, while a smooth, cool blue hue modifies it to feel passive or serene. [1]

The Ultimate Goal: Visual Semantics

Ultimately, an artist masters visual grammar to achieve Semantics—the delivery of actual meaning. When the elements (words) are expertly bound by the principles (grammar), the artwork transitions from a collection of marks into a narrative that can evoke deep emotional responses, tell complex stories, and transcend literal language barriers. [1]’

‘Self-delusion in litigation.’

Every event has an explanation –  that is a party’s ‘narrative’ in litigation. But is it credible? Is there another possible explanation and which version fits more exactly with the evidence? Witness testimony is flawed because of the failings of human memory. There is also a cognitive error driven primarily by a psychological phenomenon called ‘self-deception’, which is heavily reinforced in legal contexts by ‘myside bias’ (a specific form of ‘confirmation bias’) and ‘fabrication inflation’.

When a party fabricates or exaggerates a narrative for strategic legal reasons, several compounding cognitive processes work together to turn that deliberate contrivance into a genuinely held belief. As a result a party becomes deluded by their own false beliefs.

Psychologists use the term ‘fabrication inflation’ to describe how the act of inventing or repeating a false claim increases a person’s subjective belief that the event actually happened. Every time a litigant retells their contrived version of events – whether to their lawyer for the drafting of statements of case, or when giving oral evidence in court, the narrative becomes more familiar to their brain. Under the source monitoring framework, the brain eventually misattributes this familiarity to a real memory rather than a self-generated lie.

2. Myside Bias (‘Falling in Love with Your Case’)

Once a litigant commits to a narrative, ‘myside bias’ (or confirmation bias) takes over. The individual begins to actively filter reality, overvaluing any piece of evidence that supports their contrived story while completely discounting, ignoring, or rationalizing away glaring contradictions. In litigation, this is often exacerbated by the adversarial nature of the process, which forces parties to constantly justify their position.

3. Cognitive Dissonance and Self-Deception

Operating under high emotional and financial stress, holding a ‘gladiator-like’ public stance while secretly knowing it is a lie induces severe cognitive dissonance. To eliminate this psychological discomfort and protect their self-image as an honest, wronged party, the litigant’s brain engages in unconscious self-deception. They genuinely forget the act of fabrication and start believing their own lie to project absolute, unshakeable confidence in court.

4. Honest Lying (Confabulation)

In some cases, if the litigant begins filling in the gaps of their memory with self-serving details to the point where they can no longer separate fact from fiction, it crosses into confabulation. Often called ‘honest lying,’ the person provides false testimony without any conscious intent to deceive because their internal reality has completely shifted.

These cognitive errors can be exposed in cross-examination at trial. In Mediation they are roadblocks to a fair and sensible settlement all round. So Mediators need to be aware in order to drill down and reality-test. Thereby saving a litigant embarrassment and potentially the incurrence of catastrophic costs at the end of a Trial.

These cognitive errors and Mediator tools will be discussed in my forthcoming book – the ‘Mediation of Cultural Heritage Disputes’, see www.carlislam.co.uk

‘How in antiquity did civilizations know what precious metals and stones to look for and where to find them including copper and anthracite.’

AI – ‘In antiquity, civilizations did not rely on random exploration. They discovered precious metals and gemstones by acting as highly perceptive observers of the natural landscape, combining visual identifiers, alluvial tracking, and experiential geology. [1, 2]Without spectrometers or advanced machinery, ancient prospectors relied on specific techniques to identify and track resources like copper and anthracite coal. [1]1. Visual Indicators and Weathering SignsThe most immediate way ancient prospectors identified underground riches was through the distinct colors that exposed minerals left on the surface. [1, 2]

  • Copper: Civilizations easily spotted copper because its ore minerals—specifically malachite and azurite—weather into vibrant blue and green crusts on rock faces. Long before they understood metallurgy, humans were drawn to these stones for pigments and ornaments. When miners exhausted surface pieces of pure, “native” copper, they followed these colorful stains directly into the bedrock veins. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Anthracite and Coal: Outcrops of anthracite coal stood out starkly against surrounding sediments due to their jet-black, shiny coloration and light weight compared to standard rock. Because it was easily brittle and exposed by tectonic shifting or river cuts, ancient peoples (such as the early Romans and the Warring States in China) noticed that these “black stones” burned much longer and hotter than wood.
  • Precious Metals & Stones: Iron-rich quartz veins—which often hide gold—weather into rusty, yellowish-brown streaks against pale stone. Dense, metallic-grey cubes of galena signaled the presence of lead and silver. [1, 2, 3, 4]

2. Alluvial Prospecting (The Stream Trail)Waterways served as nature’s conveyor belts, washing dense materials down mountains. Ancient miners used a process called placer mining to track these deposits to their source. [1, 2]

  • Metals like gold, tin, and copper, as well as heavy gemstones like sapphires and rubies, have a much higher specific gravity than ordinary sand and gravel. [1]
  • Prospectors would pan riverbeds using shallow dishes or wooden trays. If they found grains of gold or chunks of copper ore in the water, they would walk upstream, continuously testing the sediment. [1, 2, 3]
  • When the traces suddenly vanished from the water, they knew the “mother lode”—the primary bedrock vein—was located on the hillside immediately above that point. [1]

3. Hydraulic Mining and “Hushing”When surface indicators suggested a mountain held hidden veins, the Romans industrialized the exploration process using a highly destructive technique called hushing. [1, 2]

  • Engineers would build complex aqueducts to channel water into massive reservoir tanks situated on hilltops above a suspected mineral site.
  • They would suddenly release the floodgates, sending a massive torrent of water roaring down the mountain slope.
  • This artificial flash flood tore away topsoil, boulders, and deep vegetation, entirely stripping the hillside bare to expose the underlying bedrock and any hidden gold or copper veins beneath. [1]

4. Direct Comparison of Ancient Sourcing Methods

MaterialPrimary Visual ClueCommon Location FoundAncient Mining Technique
CopperBright green (malachite) or blue (azurite) staining on rocks.Hydrothermal veins, mountain cliffs, and gravels.Fire-setting (cracking rock with heat and cold water) and stone hammers.
AnthraciteJet-black, glassy luster; easily fractures.Exposed river cuts, basin cliffs, and hillsides.Hand picks and surface quarrying of open seams.
GoldMetallic yellow luster; heavy, unvarnished nuggets.River gravels, alluvial bends, and white quartz veins.Stream panning, sheep fleece filters, and deep vein shafts.
Precious GemsVibrant crystals (purple amethyst, green emerald).Metamorphic rock matrix, alluvial gravel beds.Sifting riverbeds and tunneling directly into soft granite/limestone cliffs.

Through thousands of years of trial, error, and accumulated generational lore, ancient civilizations developed an incredibly sharp intuition for the Earth’s topography, realizing that certain plant types, water qualities, and rock layering consistently pointed to the riches buried beneath.’

‘How in antiquity did the architects of the monuments at Puma Punku and Tiwanaku communicate complex mathematical principles to the builders without any written notation or language?’

AI – ‘In antiquity, the architects of Puma Punku and Tiwanaku communicated complex mathematical and geometric principles to their builders without a written system by relying on an advanced “architectural grammar” encoded into physical objects and standardized workflows. [1]

Rather than utilizing blueprints on paper, they maintained extreme precision through a highly sophisticated system of physical models, modular rules, and strict operational steps:

1. Architectural Scale Models (“The Rosetta Stones”)

Architects carved scaled-down, three-dimensional physical models into smaller stone blocks to communicate full-sized structural goals. A prominent example is the famously precise stone known as the “Escritorio del Inca” (Desk of the Inca / Model Stone 1). [1]

  • Architectural analysis by researchers like Jean-Pierre Protzen revealed that this stone was actually an accurate, reduced-scale model of a full-scale architectural cornice. [1, 2]
  • By handing a stonecutter a miniature prototype containing all the correct proportions, angles, and decorative geometric ratios, the master architect provided a tactile “blueprint” that could be measured directly and scaled up by the workforce. [1]

2. Strict Modular Prefabrication

Instead of designing unique stones for every section of a building, Tiwanaku architects used a system of highly standardized, modular prefabrication. The famous H-blocks and geometric panels at Puma Punku were mass-produced to precise specifications. Because the mathematical rules (such as perfect right angles, uniform negative offsets, and standardized matching grooves) were built directly into the form of the first master molds or templates, builders did not need to understand the overarching math—they simply needed to replicate the exact dimensions of the module. [1, 2, 3, 4]

3. Procedural “Grammar” over Abstract Notation

Without written measurements (like “12.5 centimeters”), construction teams used a procedural syntax. The math was translated into a sequential checklist of physical actions:

  • Fixed Ratios via Ropes and Rods: Geometrical proportions (such as symmetry and squares) were maintained using standard units of length marked on measuring cords or rods.
  • Proportional Scaling: By using fixed lengths of rope folded into halves, thirds, or quarters, complex geometric ratios could be reliably communicated and duplicated across vast distances without a single written number.
  • Trial-Fitting and Master Templates: Master templates made of lightweight materials (such as wood or leather) were likely used to map out uniform cuts across multiple stone faces before final grinding and polishing occurred.

4. Direct Kinesthetic Learning

In the non-literate ancient Andes, technical knowledge was strictly an oral and kinesthetic tradition. Craft guilds passed down the mathematical principles of stone-cutting through years of hands-on apprenticeship. Complex spatial geometry was taught as a series of physical habits—how to strike a hammerstone, how to apply abrasive sand to flatten a surface to within 0.2mm tolerances, and how to verify flat planes using sightlines and basic leveling tools. [1, 2, 3]

By turning mathematics into a physical, modular “Lego-like” kit of parts and providing physical scale models, the architects ensured that a massive labor force could execute flawless geometric structures without ever needing to read a single line of blueprint text. …

In the absence of a written language, the architects and master builders of Tiwanaku and Puma Punku transmitted complex mathematical and architectural principles through visual prototypes, context-dependent proportions, geometric templates, and highly structured oral traditions within specialized mason guilds. [1, 2, 3]Extensive architectural studies, notably by archaeologists Jean-Pierre Protzen and Stella Nair, reveal that these ancient builders relied on highly sophisticated empirical methods rather than blueprints: [1, 2]1. Scale Models and Visual PrototypesArchitects likely used miniature stone models and structural mock-ups to communicate complex three-dimensional concepts. [1, 2]

  • At the site, archaeologists have found miniature stone models of gateways and platforms. [1]
  • These physical models allowed architects to experiment with interlocking joins, nested geometric recesses, and the famous H-blocks before directing labor on massive stones. [1, 2]
  • This visual, tactile method bypasses the need for written blueprints by using a 3D reference that any skilled builder could observe and copy. [1]

2. Proportional Logic Over Rigid MeasurementWhile some cultures used uniform ruler units, research indicates that Tiwanaku builders operated on proportional ratios and context-dependent geometry. [1]

  • Rather than measuring with a fixed universal unit across the entire city, the size of individual architectural elements was determined by their compositional context. [1]
  • For example, the gateways found throughout the complex range from tiny to monumental. However, their geometric proportions remain virtually identical. [1, 2]
  • This demonstrates that architects used a scaling factor system based on stable geometric ratios (such as right-angle triangles), which builders could reproduce at any scale using simple cords and stakes. [1, 2]

3. Integrated Grid Systems and IconographyMathematical concepts were embedded directly into the culture’s visual art and sacred iconography. [1]

  • The famous Gateway of the Sun, for example, features low-relief carvings meticulously laid out across a strict, precise square grid system. [1]
  • In a society without text, public monuments acted as permanent, open-air references. The repeating geometric motifs on friezes and textiles functioned as a visual language, standardizing mathematical relationships across generations. [1, 2, 3]

4. Master Mason Guilds and Oral KnowledgeThe ultra-precise masonry—featuring right angles, perfectly parallel channels, and uniform drill holes—was executed by hereditary or highly specialized labor guilds. [1, 2]

  • Knowledge was transmitted face-to-face from master to apprentice through rigorous, hands-on training.
  • By practicing standardized stone-cutting formulas over centuries, builders internalized the “rules of thumb” required to process exceptionally hard stones like andesite and red sandstone.
  • This oral tradition was so powerful that traces of their engineering knowledge survived in local folklore for centuries after the civilization collapsed. [1, 2, 3]’

‘The Suwałki Gap – one of the most critical geopolitical choke points in the world’

On Tuesday 20th September 2022, I attended an online Talk about the geopolitics of Kaliningrad at the Centre for Geopolitics in Cambridge University.

To hear the answer provided by Sir Stuart Peach, former Chief of the Defence Staff and Chairman of the Military Committee of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, to my Q. about Art.5 – scroll forward to 1 hour & 5 minutes.

The Suwałki Gap is a narrow, highly strategic corridor of land about 65 kilometres (40 miles) wide as the crow flies.

It runs along the border between Poland and Lithuania.

To the Northwest sits the heavily militarised Russian exclave of Kaliningrad (formerly Königsberg).

To the Southeast lies Belarus, a close ally of Moscow.

Because it is the only land link connecting the Baltic states (Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia) to the rest of their NATO allies in Europe, military planners consider it one of the most critical geopolitical choke points in the world.

Russia has explicitly threatened a full-scale military conflict and a potential nuclear strike if NATO attempts to annex, blockade, or isolate Kaliningrad or seize the Suwałki Gap.

Following accusations from Moscow that NATO was preparing an air and naval blockade in the Baltic Sea, Russia issued a formal diplomatic memo directly to NATO member states outlining its planned retaliation.

Russian President Vladimir Putin and various European embassies explicitly stated that Moscow will use all forces at its disposal, including nuclear weapons, to defend the territorial integrity of the exclave.

Russia recently updated its nuclear doctrine to explicitly allow nuclear deployment if its territories are isolated.

The diplomatic warning noted that Russia would launch immediate military strikes against decision-making centres within NATO member states right from the outset of any blockade or conflict.

Putin warned that any Western attempts to penetrate the Kaliningrad fortress or cut off its access lines would trigger an immediate, full-scale war in Europe, threatening to raze to the ground any country that participates.

Kaliningrad is already heavily militarised and hosts the Russian Baltic Fleet alongside nuclear-capable Iskander tactical missile systems.

NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte dismissed the threats as irresponsible nuclear rhetoric reiterating that NATO is a defensive alliance with no plans to blockade or invade Russian territory.

If war with Russia is inevitable, then I wonder if it will start in the Suwałki Gap?

If it does, then I also wonder whether the US will rush to the rescue of Europe?

Above all, I wonder if Burnham and his ministers understand that they are playing with fire.

Because if they make the wrong call in the belief that Russia is bluffing, it will be too late for Europe if it transpires that they were not.

So, does Burnham understand the theory and practice of ‘Deterrence’?

CThis post is written in my capacity as a graduate of what in its day was a top 5 school of Political Science in the UK, and not in any professional capacity. All opinions are purely my own. While I no longer have an interest in geopolitics, I am writing this post as an exception, because I wonder if UK politicians have made false assumptions about what Russia and the US will do if a war does start. Making assumptions at the best of times requires the exercise of highly informed and calibrated judgment. So – triggering a war against a nuclear armed power is no place for geopolitically illiterate amateurs.

I would further point out that it does not matter what NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte thinks. What is critically important is what Russia’s collective leadership elite thinks and believes. Since Rutte – who calls Trump ‘Daddy’, is not a mind reader, he cannot possibly know what is actually going on inside the head of each Russian decision-maker. That is the risk that western leaders – including Burnham and the German Chancellor are playing with, if they cross Russia’s expressly stated ‘Red Lines’.

Comments added:

Note – Google AI – ‘Both Boris Johnson and Radosław Sikorski (former Polish Foreign Minister) were both members of the Bullingdon Club while studying at the University of Oxford in the 1980s. Boris Johnson: The former British Prime Minister was a well-known member of the exclusive, raucous dining club alongside contemporaries like David Cameron and George Osborne. Radosław Sikorski: The former Polish Foreign Minister was a student contemporary of Johnson at Oxford and was also elected to and participated in the Bullingdon Club.’ Note what Colonel Daniel Davis says about those who are provoking a war with Russia – ‘We can do anything to anybody’. Isn’t that the credo of the Bullingdon Club? Is that a coincidence? – see my next comment.

Google AI – ‘The quote “We can do anything to anybody” is widely cited as the unofficial philosophy and a defining sentiment associated with the Bullingdon Club, an exclusive, private all-male dining society for students at the University of Oxford. While it functions formally as an elite drinking club, its legacy is defined by a culture of absolute privilege, entitlement, and destructive behavior. The phrase encapsulates an ethos where immense wealth and social status are believed to absolve members of legal or moral consequences. Historically, the club’s activities have reflected this attitude through several distinct behaviors:
– Deliberate Vandalism.
– Acts of Cruelty.
– Entitlement and Disdain.
Critics and biographers note that this created an environment of extreme snobbery and a perceived detachment from the lives of ordinary citizens.’

So I wonder – are other members of the UK and European elites who are pushing for a war with Russia bound together by membership of this club?
Is there a common thread linked to underlying shared interests at the expense of the civil populations of Britain and Europe – who may be conscripted to fight in a war?

See also:

Douglas Macgregor: The Truth About Kaliningrad and the NATO Crisis

Europe’s Next Flashpoint / Richard SakwaIan Proud : I Was Arrested at Heathrow!

Ian Proud : I Was Arrested at Heathrow!

The geopolitics of Kaliningrad – Centre for Geopolitics

‘Aesthetics, Philosophy, Art, Visual Culture & the Landscapes of the Ionian School.’

Aesthetics, the philosophy of art, art itself, and visual culture form an interconnected web where abstract theory meets human sensory experience and everyday life.

  • Aesthetics is the foundational branch of philosophy that studies sensory perception, beauty, and the emotional or cognitive responses we have to objects and environments. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Philosophy of art is a narrower or sister subfield that specifically questions what art is, how artworks are defined, and how we judge artistic value. [1, 2, 3]
  • Art is the physical or conceptual creation born from these values and ideas.
  • Visual culture is the broadest modern context. It takes the principles of aesthetics and art and applies them to everything we see—including mass media, digital spaces, fashion, advertising, and design. [1]

How the Four Concepts Relate

  • Theory and Practice: Aesthetics provides the philosophical toolkit (asking what is beauty? or what is truth?), which artists explore through creative practice. [1, 2]
  • From Fine Art to Everyday Sights: Historically, aesthetics and the philosophy of art focused narrowly on high art like painting and sculpture. Visual culture expands this framework, arguing that everyday images, digital media, and pop culture carry just as much aesthetic and political meaning as objects in a museum. [1, 2, 3]
  • Evolving Meaning: Thinkers like Immanuel Kant tied aesthetic judgment to universal human feelings, while G.W.F. Hegel viewed art as a reflection of culture changing over time. Visual culture updates this view, showing how our current digital and media-driven world constantly reshapes how we perceive and value the things around us. [1, 2, 3]

In the case of the Ionian School of painting (or Heptanese School) on Corfu during the 17th to 19th centuries, this nexus is a fascinating example of how political freedom, theological shifts, and artistic technique merged to create modern Greek art. [1, 2, 3]

Because the Ionian Islands bypassed Ottoman rule under Venetian, French, and British governance, Corfu became a unique multicultural crucible connecting the Eastern Mediterranean with Western Europe. Here is how the four forces of the nexus interacted through the island’s famous landscape and seascape paintings: [1]


1. Aesthetics (The Philosophy of Perception)

The philosophical engine of the Ionian School was a conscious shift from the spiritual, abstract geometry of Post-Byzantine art to the Western concept of natural veracity—the idea that “Beauty is Truth” and that the divine can be witnessed through the accurate representation of nature. [1, 2]

Pioneering Ionian theorists and artists, such as Panagiotis Doxaras, argued that to truly capture God’s creation, art had to embrace classical ideals of balance, physical grace, and mathematical order. In their philosophy, the rugged coastlines and dramatic light of Corfu were not just backdrops, but an expression of an idealized, harmonious universe. [1, 2, 3]

2. Philosophy of Art (Redefining the Image)

On Corfu, the philosophy of art underwent a secular revolution. For centuries, Greek art was strictly tied to the Maniera Greca (the traditional Byzantine style), which deliberately rejected depth and realism to focus on the eternal, non-physical realm. [1, 2]

The Ionian artists completely re-engineered what an “artwork” was supposed to do. Influenced by Italian Renaissance and Baroque academies, they introduced the concept of the landscape and seascape as independent, worthy genres of fine art. The goal of a painting transformed from providing a flat, holy icon for devotion into creating a three-dimensional visual window that captured time, atmosphere, and earthly reality. [1, 2, 3, 4]

3. Art (The Practical Execution)

This philosophical shift manifested in brilliant, tangible breakthroughs in artistic technique. Artists like Charalambos Pachis (celebrated as one of the school’s most important landscape masters) abandoned traditional egg tempera on wood panels in favour of Western oil on canvas and plein air watercolour studies. [1, 2, 3]

They mapped Corfu’s distinct terrain using specific technical tools: [1]

  • Linear and Aerial Perspective: They replaced flat Byzantine spaces with deep horizons, capturing the vastness of the Ionian Sea and receding mountain planes. [1]
  • Atmospheric Realism: Artists precisely rendered the humid maritime climate of Corfu, softening distant details—like the Albanian mountains across the strait—using Italianate tonal gradations. [1, 2]
  • The Classical Mythologizing of Space: Rather than painting unmanipulated nature, they often romanticized Corfu’s cliffs (like Palaiokastritsa) and lush olive groves to look like Homer’s mythical island of Scheria or Virgil’s pastoral Roman Arcadia. [1]

4. Visual Culture (The Social Environment)

Visual culture dictates how images function in everyday life, and on Corfu, landscapes and seascapes were deeply tied to identity and socio-political status. [1]

The local Greek aristocracy, registered in the island’s Libro d’Oro (Golden Book), used these paintings to navigate a complex dual identity. They wanted to maintain their Greek Orthodox heritage while simultaneously presenting themselves as westernized, highly sophisticated European citizens (Civiltà). Commissioning and displaying grand seascapes of Corfu’s bustling ports, coastal trade, and idyllic rural interiors became a status symbol. Furthermore, these paintings heavily interacted with the international visual culture of the era, cross-pollinating with British Romanticism and the travelogues of visiting European artists like Edward Lear, transforming Corfu into a global artistic symbol of the Mediterranean sublime. [1, 2, 3, 4]