Subject to any applicable procedural bar / defence – Yes.
English courts recognize a foreign state’s title to an antiquity if that state’s domestic law vested ownership in the state before the object was removed from its territory.
Under Law No.2863 on the Conversion of Cultural and Natural Property 1983 (and its predecessor laws), all movable and immovable cultural property found on or under the ground or water in Turkey automatically belongs to the State from the moment of discovery or existence.
In landmark cases such as Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran v The Barakat Galleries Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 1374, the Court of Appeal confirmed that a foreign state can sue in London to recover antiquities if its domestic law clearly conferred immediate ownership in the state.
So, once Turkish state ownership is established under the lex situs, Turkey can sue the UK dealer, auction house, or possessor in the High Court for Conversion.
Under the Torts (Interference with Goods Act) 1977, anyone who possesses, offers for sale, or transfers a stolen item commits the tort of conversion against the true owner, regardless of whether they bought it in good faith.
Under English law (nemo dat quod non habet – ‘no one gives what they do not have’), a thief cannot pass good title to a buyer, meaning even an innocent UK buyer does not acquire legal ownership against Turkey.
Note that under the Dealing in Cultural Objects (Offences) Act 2003 and UNESCO conventions, dealing in illicitly excavated or unlawfully exported antiquities is a criminal offence. Thus, reputable UK auction houses and dealers will not handle unprovenanced or recently removed Turkish artefacts.CMainstream archaeologists estimate that the underwater structures recently discovered in Turkey’s Lake Van are between 1000 – 3000 years old.
Independent researchers and podcasters, such as Matthew LaCroix, have proposed that deeper circular stone structures and causeways found 75 to 80 feet below the surface belong to a forgotten Ice Age civilization.
In other words, that they are more than 40,000 years old.
This theory is based upon why these ancient ruins were found at such a depth in this particular inland lake.
AI – ‘Researchers involved in diving expeditions estimate that less than 1% of the lake itself has been explored.
Systematic underwater archaeological surveys and mapping have not been completed, meaning the full size of the submerged settlement remains unknown. During dives off the northern shore, researchers measured stonework extending over 45 metres before it disappeared beyond their field of view.
Divers have documented a roughly 1-kilometre-long stone fortress near Adilcevaz, alongside circular formations, stone walls, and a submerged village with streets and cemeteries at depths of around 23 metres.
Much of the architecture remains buried beneath lakebed mud. Collecting organic samples from deep sediment layers for definitive dating is difficult, leaving the age of the ruins debated between the medieval era, the 3,000-year-old Urartian period, and much earlier prehistoric eras.
Drought and climate shifts have caused Lake Van’s shoreline to retreat in recent years, naturally exposing previously submerged structures—such as Ottoman piers and roughly 80% of a 1-kilometre ancient stone road leading toward Çarpanak Island.’
Egypt can also bring a patrimonial claim in the High Court in London to recover recently discovered artefacts found on land or within its territorial waters. Experts estimate that between less than 1% and roughly 30% of ancient Egypt’s archaeological sites have been excavated. Some important sites – including lost cities, are underwater.
In relation to recently discovered antiquities found on land or under water – almost all states in Central and South America can bring a patrimonial claim in the High Court in London. Almost every country in the region has enacted strict ‘patrimony’ or ‘vesting’ legislation declaring undiscovered archaeological and underwater cultural heritage to be the ‘inalienable’ property of the state.
Experts estimate that well under 1% to 5% of ancient archaeological sites on land, and less than 0.1% of underwater sites, have been excavated across Central and South America.
Over 35 African states have enacted domestic cultural heritage legislation vesting ownership of recently discovered antiquities in the state, though an important legal distinction exists between states whose laws cover both land and territorial waters versus those whose statutes vest ownership only for terrestrial (land) discoveries or rely on state custody/control rather than outright title.
Experts estimate that well under 1% of ancient archaeological sites on land, and less than 0.01% of underwater sites, have been excavated across the African continent.